Pete Alonso’s Two Homers Sink Blue Jays 4-3
Three Baltimore scoring swings were enough to turn Toronto’s early comfort into another late September bruise.
Some losses come with clutter.
Errors, walks, weird bounces, missed chances stacked so high that you need a small municipal crew to sort the wreckage.
Monday’s 4-3 Blue Jays loss to the Baltimore Orioles was not like that.
It was painfully legible.
Nathan Lukes, George Springer, and Sean Keys helped build a 3-run top of the first.
Then Pete Alonso hit one out.
Then Gunnar Henderson hit one out.
Then Pete Alonso hit another one out.
That was enough.
Toronto and Baltimore each finished with 6 hits.
Both teams made 0 errors.
The Blue Jays left 4 on base. The Orioles left 3.
If you were looking for the hidden mechanism, there was not much hiding.
Baltimore’s runs came on the swings that Toronto could not survive.
Alonso opened the wound and closed it
The first Baltimore scoring play came in the bottom of the first.
Pete Alonso homered, his 39th, on a fly ball to right field off Trey Yesavage.
A 3-run Toronto first had barely had time to feel sturdy before the Orioles started sanding it down.
The second Baltimore scoring play came in the bottom of the sixth.
Gunnar Henderson homered, his 24th, on a fly ball to right field off Chad Dallas.
Then came the bottom of the eighth, because of course it did.
Alonso homered again, his 40th, on a fly ball to left field off Tyler Rogers. Christian Franklin scored.
That is a brutal little ledger.
Alonso in the first.
Henderson in the sixth.
Alonso in the eighth.
No need for poetry when the pain is this administratively complete.
The Jays did not lose because Baltimore sprayed the ball all over the yard inning after inning.
They lost because the Orioles got the exact damage they needed at the exact times Toronto could least afford it.
Toronto’s first inning deserved a better life
The top of the first was good baseball.
Let us at least give it that.
Against Shane Baz, Nathan Lukes singled on a line drive to left fielder Dylan Beavers. Brett Bateman scored. Alejandro Kirk moved to second.
George Springer followed with a single on a line drive to left fielder Dylan Beavers. Kirk scored. Lukes went to third.
Sean Keys then hit a sacrifice fly to right fielder Rece Hinds, scoring Lukes.
That is not nothing.
That is sequencing.
That is pressure.
That is the kind of inning this team has so often needed and so often treated like an exotic bird seen briefly in the alley.
Springer finished 2-for-4 with an RBI.
Lukes finished 1-for-3 with an RBI.
Keys finished 0-for-3 with an RBI.
Alejandro Kirk went 1-for-3. Andrés Giménez went 1-for-3. Kazuma Okamoto went 1-for-4.
There were pieces.
The sadness is that the pieces did not become a game.
They became a first inning, and then a long wait.
The pitching line had useful things in it
This is the part that makes the loss feel especially weary.
Toronto’s staff had 10 strikeouts.
That number should usually buy you a better mood than this.
Chad Dallas worked 2.2 innings with 1 earned run and 4 strikeouts.
Brendan Cellucci had 1.1 innings with 0 earned runs and 3 strikeouts.
Trey Yesavage had 2.0 innings with 1 earned run and 3 strikeouts.
José Rodríguez gave 1.0 inning with 0 earned runs.
Mason Fluharty had 0.2 innings with 1 earned run. Tyler Rogers had 0.1 innings with 1 earned run.
The total was 4 earned runs.
That matches the score, and the score is the problem.
There are nights when 4 allowed feels survivable.
There are nights when it feels like asking this offense to carry a piano up a wet hill.
Monday became the second kind.
The pitching did not get shredded all night.
It got beaten in the precise places that mattered most.
The silence after the first was the old song
After the top of the first, the Blue Jays put zeroes beside their name the rest of the way.
The top of the ninth included one more of them.
That is the detail that lingers.
Not just that Toronto lost.
That Toronto had already shown the version of itself capable of winning, then could not summon it again.
Josh Smith went 0-for-4. Ernie Clement went 0-for-3. Myles Straw went 0-for-2. Brett Bateman went 0-for-1.
Nobody needs to be turned into a villain here.
Baseball provides plenty of loss without asking us to invent malice.
But performance is performance, and Monday’s offense after the first inning was a closed door with the lights off behind it.
Now the standings read 77-80, .490, 4th in the division, 4-6 over the last ten, L1.
Through 157 games, the Blue Jays have 632 runs, 4.03 runs per game, a .248 batting average, a .692 OPS, and 149 home runs.
Those numbers are not empty.
They are just not comforting.
Today, Toronto gets Baltimore again, with Max Scherzer listed against Chris Bassitt.
Another game, same road, same late-September arithmetic.
Monday did not ask for much imagination.
It only asked us to watch a lead become a memory.
React to this rant